The hype for EB Matte Lipstick in Toast of New York when so beyond out of control over social media that the specific shade is completely out of stock across all Ever Bilena stalls nationwide, except for maybe select small outlets that do not have as much customer traffic.
Good news though, because there are ways to go around it from the closest dupe to mixing and matching to reach that darker MLBB color!
Top row left to right: 1 – EB Matte Liquid Lipstick in Dusk, 2 – EB Matte Lipstick Port + Sexy Nude, 3 – Mirrored Mocha Lip Liner + Siennas Lip Liner, 4 – Careline Matte Liquid Lipstick in Normcore, 5 – Careline Matte Liquid Lipstick in Tutu, 6 – Tutu + Normcore, 7 – EB Liquid Lipstick City Romance in C02 + EB Liquid Lipstick Aura, 8 – EB Matte Lipstick in Port + Mauvey, 9 – EB Advance LTD Liquid Lipstick in Chocolate Truffle + Skinny Dip, 10 – Chocolate Truffle + Private Beach, 11 – EB Matte Lipstick in Port + Mirrored Mocha, 12 – Dusk + Mirrored Mocha.
Bottom row left to right: 13 EB Matte Liquid Lipstick Toast of New York, 14 EB Matte Lipstick in Toast of New York (what you’re most likely on this blog entry for!), 15 EB Matte Mirrored Mocha, 16 Mirrored Mocha Lip Liner, 17 EB Matte Liquid Lipstick Siennas, 18 Siennas Lip Liner, 19 EB Matte Lipstick Siennas, 20 Port, 21 Dusk, 22 EB Matte Lipstick Sexy Nude, 23 Dusk + Siennas, 24 Port + Siennas
Among all the bullet lipstick swatch combinations, I’d say swatch #20 Port and #24 Port + Siennas are closest to #14 Toast of New York.
I’m wearing EB Matte Liquid Lipstick in Toast of NY in the photo above.
For liquid lipstick mixes, closest to the #13 Liquid Lipstick version of Toast of New York and its bullet version color #14 Toast of New York are: #9 EB Advance LTD Liquid Lipstick in Chocolate Truffle + Skinny Dip, #10 Chocolate Truffle + Private Beach, and #1 Dusk.
If you’re looking for single lipstick dupes, I would recommend: Mirrored Mocha, Port, and Siennas; and playing around with the three shades. All are beautiful colors anyway, as seen in the lip swatch collage below.
All shades mentioned above are extremely affordable. EB Matte Bullet Lipsticks (original) are P165, EB Matte Liquid Lipsticks P195, EB Advance LTD Liquid Lipsticks P185, EB Matte Lip Liner P120, EB Liquid Lipstick (chubby) P185, EB City Romance Liquid Lipstick Set of 3 P399, and Careline Matte Liquid Lipstick P210.